LISTEN TO THIS ARTICLE
For responsible concealed carry permit holders, understanding what constitutes “brandishing” a firearm is essential knowledge. The line between legally carrying a concealed firearm and illegally displaying or brandishing it can sometimes be thin, yet the legal consequences of crossing that line can be severe. This article aims to educate concealed carry holders about brandishing laws, helping them avoid legal pitfalls while exercising their Second Amendment rights.
What Is Brandishing a Firearm?
Brandishing a firearm generally refers to displaying, showing, waving, or exhibiting a gun in a threatening, aggressive, or intimidating manner.
Brandishing typically includes displaying a firearm in a way that causes fear or alarm in others, using a gun to intimidate or threaten another person, unnecessarily revealing or drawing attention to a concealed firearm, or pointing or waving a firearm in the presence of others.
The key element that separates legal carrying from illegal brandishing is typically the intent and manner of display. Merely having a firearm visible (in states where open carry is legal) does not constitute brandishing. The display generally must include some element of threatening behavior or intent to intimidate.
Is Brandishing a Firearm Illegal?
In short: Yes, brandishing a firearm is illegal in all 50 states, though the specific language, definitions, and penalties vary significantly by jurisdiction.
State-by-State Variations
While brandishing is universally prohibited, states use different terminology and have different thresholds:
Some states explicitly use the term “brandishing” in their statutes, while others refer to it as “improper display,” “exhibiting,” or “flourishing” a firearm. Some jurisdictions include brandishing under broader assault or menacing statutes. Regardless of terminology, penalties can range from misdemeanors to felonies depending on the specific circumstances of the incident.
Common Elements of Brandishing Laws
Despite variations, most state laws consider many factors when determining if brandishing has occurred. These include intent (whether the firearm was displayed to cause fear or intimidate), reasonable fear (if a reasonable person would feel threatened by the display), necessity (whether displaying the firearm was necessary under the circumstances), and context (considering where and when the display occurred).
Legal Consequences of Brandishing a Firearm
The penalties for brandishing a firearm can be severe. Depending on the circumstances and state law, you may face misdemeanor or felony charges with fines ranging from hundreds to thousands of dollars. Many offenses carry jail or prison time, typically from months to several years. Beyond criminal penalties, you might also face permanent loss of firearm rights, revocation of concealed carry permits, and potential civil liability if someone claims emotional distress or injury from the incident.
Common Scenarios That May Constitute Brandishing
Concealed carry holders should be aware of these potentially problematic situations:
Road Rage Incidents
One of the most common brandishing a firearm scenarios occurs during traffic disputes. Revealing or gesturing toward your firearm during a disagreement with another driver almost always constitutes illegal brandishing.
Verbal Arguments
Displaying a firearm during a verbal altercation—even without explicitly threatening anyone—can constitute brandishing if the display was intended to intimidate.
“Gun-Checking”
Repeatedly touching, adjusting, or checking your concealed firearm in public, drawing attention to it, could potentially be interpreted as brandishing in some jurisdictions.
Improper Printing or Exposure
While unintentional “printing” (when the outline of a concealed firearm is visible through clothing) is generally not brandishing, deliberately allowing your firearm to become visible to intimidate others could cross the line.
Self-Defense vs. Brandishing a Firearm
One of the most critical distinctions concealed carry holders must understand is the difference between legitimate self-defense and illegal brandishing.
When Drawing a Firearm May Be Legal
Drawing or displaying a firearm may be legally justified in certain circumstances. These generally include situations where you are facing an imminent threat of death or great bodily harm and a reasonable person would believe deadly force might be necessary. Additionally, in “duty to retreat” states, you typically must have no safe alternative or opportunity to retreat. It’s also important that you are not the initial aggressor in the conflict, as this can significantly impact your legal standing.
The Problem of “Defensive Display”
Some states recognize the concept of “defensive display” or “defensive brandishing,” where revealing a firearm to deter an attack without firing may be legally justified. However:
- Many states have no such provision
- Even in states that do, the threat must generally be immediate and serious
- The burden of proving the display was defensive falls on you
Best Practices for Concealed Carry Holders
To avoid brandishing charges while lawfully carrying a concealed firearm:
- Keep it truly concealed: Ensure your firearm remains fully concealed unless you face a legitimate threat requiring its use.
- Avoid confrontation: The best self-defense strategy is avoiding conflict entirely. Walk away from arguments and de-escalate tense situations.
- Never use your firearm as a threat: Your concealed firearm is a last-resort self-defense tool, not a means of winning arguments or asserting dominance.
- Know when drawing is justified: Understand your state’s self-defense laws and the threshold for legally displaying or using a firearm.
- Consider alternatives: In many situations, less-lethal options or retreat may be more appropriate than displaying a firearm.
- Document incidents: If you ever do display your firearm in what you believe is self-defense, document everything and report the incident to law enforcement immediately.
State-Specific Considerations
While this article provides general information applicable across the United States, concealed carry holders should research the specific laws in:
- Their home state
- Any states they regularly visit
- States they plan to travel through (considering reciprocity agreements)
Some states have explicit brandishing statutes with clear definitions, while others address the behavior under broader threatening or assault statutes.
Conclusion
For responsible concealed carry holders, understanding brandishing a firearm laws is as important as knowing how to safely handle your firearm. By keeping your firearm properly concealed except in genuine self-defense situations, avoiding confrontation, and understanding relevant laws, you can exercise your rights while minimizing legal risks.
Remember that responsible firearm ownership includes not only safe handling practices but also ensuring your actions with a firearm remain within the bounds of the law.
Disclaimer
This article is provided for informational and educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Laws regarding firearms vary significantly by state and local jurisdiction and are subject to change. This information should not be relied upon as a substitute for consultation with a qualified attorney in your jurisdiction. Readers should consult with a licensed attorney familiar with the firearm laws in their specific location for guidance tailored to their individual circumstances.
Read full article here
