- A meteor impact 56,000 years ago at Arizona’s Barringer Crater may have triggered a Grand Canyon landslide, forming a dam and paleolake.
- Researchers linked the impact’s seismic waves to a massive cliff collapse via radiocarbon and luminescence dating of driftwood and cave sediments.
- Shockwaves from the cosmic collision, calculated as a M3.5 quake at the Grand Canyon, caused a landslide that dammed the Colorado River.
- Driftwood deposits in caves 150 feet above the river underscore the colossal scale of the ancient flooding event.
- The study bridges two previously unrelated events, showcasing the interconnectedness of Earth’s geological systems.
Geologists have long marveled at the Grand Canyon’s haunting beauty, a landscape carved over millions of years by the Colorado River. Now, a landmark study reveals the river’s path—and possibly the canyon itself—may have been dramatically altered by a catastrophic cosmic event. A meteor impact near present-day Flagstaff, Arizona, 56,000 years ago likely sent seismic tremors along 160 kilometers to the Grand Canyon, toppling a massive cliffside, damming the river and creating a lake that flooded the canyon to unparalleled depths. Published in Geology by a team led by University of New Mexico researchers Karl Karlstrom and Laurie Crossey, this discovery redefines the canyon’s dynamic history and highlights how ancient geological events remain intertwined across vast distances.
The fateful coincidence: A cosmic chain reaction
The story begins with Arizona’s Barringer Crater—or Meteor Crater—as its culprit. Formed when a 40-meter-wide iron asteroid slammed into Earth, the crater’s origin has been dated to between 53,000 and 63,000 years ago. Prior research by co-author David Kring, a planetary scientist at the Lunar and Planetary Institute, estimated the impact triggered a magnitude 5.4 earthquake near the crater itself. But new calculations show that even after traveling over 100 miles (160 km), the shockwaves retained enough force to generate a M3.5 quake at the Grand Canyon—a vibration sufficient to destabilize the canyon’s steep cliffs.
“We’re talking about a rare confluence of events,” Karlstrom said. “The timing of the meteor impact aligns uncannily with the landslide-dam event right here in the canyon.” The dam, hundreds of feet thick and nearly a mile wide, blocked the Colorado River near Nankoweap Canyon, creating a lake that stretched 65 miles (105 km) upstream. Water levels could have risen more than 150 feet (46 m), depositing driftwood high inside caves like Stanton’s Cave—46 m above the river.
Decoding driftwood: Clues from ancient caves
The driftwood’s origins had puzzled scientists since the 1960s, when University of New Mexico geologist Thor Karlstrom (Karl’s father) and his team uncovered layers of organic material in Stanton’s Cave. Early radiocarbon dating placed the wood at over 35,000 years old, but techniques available then had limits. Modern methods, including radiocarbon tests at Australian and New Zealand laboratories and luminescence dating of sediment samples by Tammy Rittenour at Utah State University, narrowed the timeframe to 55,250 ± 2,440 years ago for the driftwood and 56,000 ± 6,390 years ago for associated lake sediments.
These findings align nearly perfectly with revised estimates of the Meteor Crater’s age, based on argon dating and quartz shock deformation studies by Kring. “We had two independent datasets converging—the impact’s timeline and the flood evidence,” said co-author Laura Crossey. “The numbers kept whispering the same story.”
The team also found beaver tracks in Vasey’s Paradise Cave, 37 meters above the river. Such high-elevation traces suggest beavers navigated waters generated by the paleolake—a clue underscoring the lake’s scale.
The physics of impact: Calculating the seismic link
Linking the meteor impact to the landslide required navigating complex transmission of energy via Earth’s crust. Kring, an expert in impact dynamics, modeled how the meteor’s punch transformed into surface waves. “The rock composition between Meteor Crater and the Grand Canyon acts like a waveguide,” he explained. The shockwaves, though greatly diminished over distance, transmitted enough force to weaken Grand Canyon’s preexisting tectonic fractures.
“This wasn’t a direct hit,” said Karlstrom. “It’s like cracking a window when you shake a whole building. The canyon’s cliffs were already on the edge of instability.” The resulting landslide—part of the canyon’s “Nankoweap Delta”—left behind 90-foot-thick debris at the dam site, later eroded as floodwaters breached the barrier. The lake itself may have persisted only a few centuries before sediment choked its flow.
Paleolake legacy: Echoes of a transient landscape
The dam’s short-lived existence doesn’t diminish its significance. At its peak, the lake—spanning modern-day Marble Canyon—likely dwarfed any recorded flooding in the region. Karlstrom noted it would require water 10 times greater than historical deluges to lift driftwood into Stanton’s Cave’s lofty niche. The waters also altered the canyon’s flora and fauna, offering a temporary niche for species like the extinct California condor, whose bone fragments were found among the driftwood.
The study’s cross-disciplinary approach—combining astrophysics, sedimentology and archaeology—spotlights the necessity of linking diverse datasets. “Geology is full of detective stories,” said Karlstrom. “Here, we’ve woven together clues from space, rock and ancient organic matter to solve a 56,000-year-old puzzle.”
Implications for geology: Challenging assumptions
The findings upend the notion that the Grand Canyon’s formation is primarily a slow, incremental process. “This shows rapid, episodic events—like impacts or landslides—can create dramatic shortfalls in geological timescales,” Karlstrom said. The study also underscores why scientists must reassess assumptions about seemingly unrelated events. Previously, the Meteor Crater impact and Grand Canyon landmarks like the Nankoweap Delta were studied in isolation.
Such insights matter today as climate change and urbanization expose humanity’s vulnerability to extreme events. “Landslide dams can form suddenly and have catastrophic consequences,” said Crossey. “This isn’t just ancient history—it’s a reminder of Earth’s dynamic nature.” The tale also ties back to the enduring impact of storytelling in science. Karlstrom’s father, Thor, died in 1998; his fieldwork laid the groundwork for a discovery he lived to see published.
The Grand Canyon’s cosmic blueprint
The Grand Canyon, more than just a testament to millennia of erosion, now stands as a monument to interconnected cosmic and terrestrial forces. A single meteor strike 56,000 years ago set in motion a chain of effects rippling across the American Southwest. For a region celebrated for its geological grandeur, this study reminds us: nature’s script is rarely linear, and its most profound lessons often lie hidden, awaiting the right question or the right tool to draw them out.
Sources for this article include:
LiveScience.com
News.UNM.edu
Pubs.GeoScienceWorld.org
Read full article here