- Excessive thinking, or rumination, is linked to physical health issues, particularly digestive problems, according to both ancient Traditional Chinese Medicine and modern science.
- In TCM, the spleen is viewed as a holistic system governing both digestion and thought, where overthinking can directly weaken digestive function.
- Historical medical cases demonstrate the use of emotional counterbalancing, like provoking anger to break a cycle of worry, to treat physical ailments rooted in mental fixation.
- Modern research supports a gut-brain connection, showing gut microbiota influences cognitive function, memory and brain structure.
- Chronic overthinking is associated with anxiety, depression and physical symptoms like fatigue and headaches, requiring proactive strategies to manage thought patterns.
In the 14th century, a physician named Zhu Zhenheng healed a bedridden young woman not with herbs, but with a calculated insult. Her ailment, diagnosed as lovesickness, had sapped her appetite for months. Zhu’s method—provoking her anger—triggered an emotional release that miraculously restored her hunger. This ancient case, recorded in Chinese medical literature, illustrates a core tenet of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM): the mind and body are inextricably linked, and excessive thinking can cause tangible physical illness, particularly in digestion. Today, modern science is uncovering the biological pathways of this ancient insight, revealing how chronic rumination can strain both mental and physical health.
The spleen: A bridge between thought and digestion
The TCM concept of the spleen is far broader than its Western anatomical counterpart. It is considered a functional system encompassing digestion, nutrient absorption and even cognitive processes like thinking and concentration. Dr. Lai Kok, a TCM practitioner in Hong Kong, explains that the spleen governs a range of abdominal organs. When functioning well, it supports clear thought and a healthy physique. However, TCM holds that excessive thinking, worry or rumination—known as “overthinking the spleen”—can deplete this system’s energy, leading to physical symptoms like poor appetite, bloating, fatigue and a sallow complexion.
This perspective finds a parallel in modern gut-brain axis research. A 2020 narrative review in Nutrients concluded that gut microbiota is closely linked to cognitive performance, with interventions to modify gut bacteria showing promise in improving memory, learning and attention. This bidirectional communication network provides a scientific framework for understanding how mental states can influence gut health and vice versa.
The five elements and emotional counterbalance
TCM organizes the body and emotions within a Five Elements framework (wood, fire, earth, metal, water). The spleen is associated with the earth element and the emotion of worry. Crucially, these elements interact in cycles of control. The liver, linked to the wood element and the emotion of anger, naturally controls or regulates the spleen (earth). In the historical case, Physician Zhu applied this principle therapeutically. By deliberately inciting anger, he used the liver’s energy to break the stagnant, worrisome thought pattern that was damaging the young woman’s spleen and digestive function. Her emotional outburst served as a reset, clearing the mental blockage and allowing physical recovery to begin.
When modern overthinking becomes harmful
Contemporary psychology echoes the dangers of persistent, unproductive thought patterns. “Overthinking is when you dwell on possibilities and pitfalls without any real intent of solving a problem,” says Dr. J. Christopher Fowler, a wellness expert. Signs include relentless second-guessing, fixating on past mistakes or uncontrollable future outcomes, and experiencing “analysis paralysis.” The consequences extend beyond mental fatigue. Chronic rumination is a known risk factor for anxiety and depression, which carry physical symptoms like headaches, nausea, sleep disturbances and difficulty concentrating. Furthermore, Dr. Fowler notes that generalized anxiety is linked to poorer cardiovascular health, demonstrating the systemic impact of sustained mental stress.
Nourishing the mind-gut axis
Both ancient and modern practices offer strategies to strengthen resilience against overthinking. TCM emphasizes nourishing the spleen system with warm, easily digestible foods, particularly in late summer when it is considered most vulnerable. Dietary recommendations center on yellow and sweet whole foods like pumpkin, sweet potatoes and grains such as millet and oats, which are believed to support digestive and cognitive function. From a behavioral standpoint, experts recommend practical steps to curb rumination: differentiate between solvable problems and unsolvable “gravity problems,” set deadlines for decision-making to prevent endless analysis, and combine logical research with trusting one’s instinct. The goal is to shift from passive worrying to active problem-solving or conscious release.
An enduring truth of holistic health
The tale of the lovesick maiden and the physician’s unconventional cure is more than a historical anecdote; it is a timeless reminder of psychosomatic unity. The emerging science of the gut-brain axis now provides a biological language for this ancient wisdom, confirming that our digestive well-being is profoundly influenced by our cognitive and emotional states. In an age of constant mental stimulation and stress, the imperative to manage our thought patterns is not merely a pursuit of mental peace but a critical component of sustaining physical health. The path to wellness requires caring for both the mind that ruminates and the gut that feels the effects.
Sources for this article include:
TheEpochTimes.com
MDPI.com
HoustonMethodist.org
Read full article here