A pro-Israel rally in Newton turned violent when a pro-Palestine protester attacked Iraq War veteran Scott Hayes, leading to a gunshot that injured the attacker. Hayes, charged with assault and battery with a dangerous weapon, claims self-defense.

NEWTON, MA (3-minute read) — Tensions flared during a pro-Israel rally in Newton when an Iraq War veteran, Scott Hayes, found himself at the center of a violent altercation with a pro-Palestinian protester, resulting in a gunshot that injured the attacker. Cell phone footage captured the incident, showing the protester, identified as Caleb Gannon, 31, crossing the street and physically attacking Hayes before the shot was fired.

The clash took place on Thursday evening near the corner of Harvard and Washington Streets, where Hayes, 47, was part of a small group supporting Israel. Gannon, who had been shouting from across the street, suddenly rushed towards Hayes, knocking him to the ground. As they grappled on the pavement, a shot was fired, leaving Gannon wounded.

Scott Hayes charged directly after incident

Hayes was arrested at the scene and has since pleaded not guilty to assault and battery with a dangerous weapon. Appearing in Newton District Court, Hayes had visible bruises and scratches, underscoring the physical nature of the altercation. He was released on bail set at $50,000 with strict conditions, including wearing a GPS monitor, staying away from the man he shot and the city of Newton, and abiding by a nightly curfew. His license to carry has also been suspended pending the outcome of the investigation.

The defense claims that Hayes was acting in self-defense after being attacked. “This is a textbook case of self-defense,” said his attorney, Glenn MacKinley, expressing confidence that once the investigation is complete, Hayes will be cleared of all charges. Supporters of Hayes, who gathered at the courthouse, echoed the sentiment, arguing that he should never have been charged in the first place.

Prosecutors have indicated that Gannon, who survived the shooting, will also face charges for his role in the incident. Middlesex District Attorney Marian Ryan confirmed that Gannon is expected to recover, though his condition was unclear on Friday. The exact nature of the charges against him has yet to be disclosed, but it is expected that he will be held accountable for the initial assault.

JUST IN: Newton, MA: An Iraq War vet, Scott Hayes, faces charges after defending himself at a pro-Israel rally. Despite clear self-defense, the DA’s office charges him with assault and rights violation. This decision has sparked a debate on self-defense rights and political bias… pic.twitter.com/7xPXztjAe6

— Political Truthr 🇺🇸 (@PoliticalTruthr) September 13, 2024

Videos captured by bystanders show the tense moments leading up to the gunshot. In one clip, Gannon can be heard shouting at the group of pro-Israel demonstrators, accusing them of supporting genocide. He then charges across the street and tackles Hayes, initiating the violent encounter. As the two wrestled, Hayes reportedly called out for help, instructing others to grab his pistol. After the shot, Hayes is seen offering aid to Gannon, urging someone to call 911 while rendering first aid.

As the legal process unfolds, the community remains divided. Newton Mayor Ruthanne Fuller called the shooting “frightening and disturbing,” while also commending the professionalism of law enforcement. In response to the incident, local authorities have increased patrols around places of worship and are urging residents to stay calm.

Hayes is due back in court in November, and both sides are preparing for what is likely to be a highly scrutinized trial.

Safety Tip: Always be aware of your surroundings when attending public gatherings, especially protests. If you carry a firearm, ensure you understand local laws regarding self-defense and use of force.